Michael Egan - From Treasury to Torrens, Tracing a Colonial Legacy

Architect: Michael Egan (c.1846 - 1912)
Early Life and Family
Michael Egan was born around 1846 in Athlone, Westmeath, Ireland. He migrated to Melbourne as a child with his family, sometime between 1854 and 1868. He was the third son of Bridget Corcoran and Michael Egan Sr., who notably served as both Councillor and Mayor of Richmond.
Architectural Career and Public Works
Michael Egan established himself as a Victorian-era architect based in Melbourne during the mid nineteenth century, with the gold rush, population growth and rising wealth, spurred public works, major buildings and ambitious infrastructure. It was in this atmosphere that Michael Egan made his mark as an architect, especially through public commissions and competitions. He is recognised for significant contributions to public works during the 1860s and 1870s. Egan is best known for winning the competition to design the Government Offices at No. 2 Treasury Place. His professional portfolio includes a range of projects for the Public Works Department, such as bridges, wharves, and other government buildings.
In his early years, Egan is believed to have worked for John Flannagan, the first architect of the Mechanics Institute, Williamstown. County Court records detail a dispute between Egan and Flannagan, where Egan sued for unpaid wages and reimbursement of a premium paid to learn the profession of surveyor and architect. Egan claimed Flannagan refused to instruct him, while Flannagan accused Egan of being 'systematically brusque' to customers. The court awarded Egan £38. (The Age, quoting McIvor Times, 25 September 1863).
Notable works
Egan’s design for the new Government Offices at No. 2 Treasury Place, Melbourne, is frequently referenced in local historical accounts. His winning entry, selected in 1859, was initially considered ‘a bit plain’ and was subsequently modified to include columns and a decorative portico. Although the foundation was laid in 1859, construction was delayed until 1875–76.
In March 1869, Egan was recorded in Richmond Council Minutes as being awarded second place by esteemed architect William Wardell for his designs for the Richmond Town Hall. During this period, Egan’s father, Michael Snr. was serving as Councillor and Mayor of Richmond.
Among his major accomplishments is the design of the Torrens Building at 202-220 Victoria Square, Adelaide. Designed in 1877 and completed by April 1881, the Torrens Building is described as “the best remaining example in Adelaide of Italian Renaissance or Neo-Classical style with a Palladian composition.” It remains one of South Australia’s most notable surviving government buildings. During this period, Egan also submitted a design for the University of Adelaide’s first building (later known as the Mitchell Building), winning second prize in the competition. Although initially appointed as architect and tasked with producing working drawings, Egan’s design was ultimately considered too expensive, and the committee engaged William McMinn to amend it. The completed building is often attributed to McMinn, though many sources note its strong resemblance to Egan’s original design.
Egan maintained offices first at 76 Collins Street and later at Oriental House, 28 William Street, Melbourne, as reported in The Argus.
Commercial and Residential Buildings
In Williamstown, Egan designed four two-storey shops adjoining the Pier Hotel in 1872 for Mr S. H. Sandford. He was also engaged to design four two-storey bluestone shops at 131–137 Nelson Place, constructed between 1873 and 1875 for Mrs Crane and Mr Peter Power.
In 1874, Egan was commissioned by William Pearson, a Williamstown Councillor and later Mayor, to design the Crown Hotel on the corner of Pasco and Cecil Street. Pearson, who was also the licensee, required a residence next to the hotel, and Egan designed a two-storey Victorian Italianate terrace house at 160 Cecil Street in 1875, both are still standing today. Additionally, Egan was tasked with sourcing suitable stonemasons for the foundation stone of the Wilkinson Memorial Fountain in Nelson Place, and he advertised for builders for a boat shed for the Williamstown Rowing Club in 1876.
Egan designed additional two-storey Nelson Parade residences for Messrs Peter Murray and James Anderson, as well as the Williamstown Gas Co. Retort House in 1877. In January 1881, he called for tenders to construct a two-storey shop and dwelling for Mr John Morgan in Nelson Place.
He was also commissioned to prepare plans for a two-storey house in Brighton for Mr Thomas Bent MLA in 1877. Thomas Bent would later become Victorian Premier and Treasurer (1904–1909). Egan is further listed as architect for various residential buildings in Brighton, Toorak, South Yarra, Richmond, St Kilda, and Williamstown through to 1881.
Williamstown Mechanics Institute - Stage 3, 1880
The committee of the Mechanics Institute, engaged the services of Michael Egan for alterations and remedial work to the hall, as well as additions in the form of the Southern wing of the building. In March 1880, Egan called for tenders, with Mr V Riadden later listed as the builder. This commission likely arose as William Pearson was on the committee of the Mechanics Institute at this time, and Egan had previously completed architectural designs and buildings for Pearson in 1874–75.
Later recognition and legacy
In 1881, Michael Egan won an award at the International Exhibition for his architectural drawings. He also submitted a design for Flinders Street Station. Although unsuccessful, his plans were purchased for £50 due to their notable merit (The Argus, 20 April 1883, p. 6). Many of Egans works are now heritage listed with No.2 Treasury Place, Melbourne and the Torrens Building in Adelaide recognised an exceptional nineteenth century buildings.
Michael Egan passed away on 23 October 1912 at the age of 66.
If you would like to read more about the Williamstown Mechanics Institute, please click here
References:
- Australian Architects Index. The Age quoted McIvor Times, 25 September 1863
- The Argus, 11 Sep 1875, page 11
- Australian Architectural Index File. Record 41454. The Argus 1 May 1872, page 3
- Australian Architectural Index File. The Argus, 4 Aug 1871, page 3
- Australian Architectural Index File. Record 45774. The Argus, 25 Sep 1876, page 3
- Australian Architectural Index file. Record18578. The Argus, 21 Jan 1874, page 3.
- Williamstown Advertiser (Vic.:1875-1954), Saturady 15 January, 1881. Page 2
- Australian Architectural Index file. Record 32607. The Argus, 1 Oct, 1875. Page 2
- Australian Architectural Index File. Record 13401. Registration 566. The Argus, 21 May 1877, page 3
- Williamstown Advertiser (Vic.:1875-1954), Saturady 15 January, 1881. Page 2
- Australian Architectural Index file. Record 22003. The Argus, 6 Jan 1877, page 11
- E Melbourne. The City past & present https://www.emelbourne.net.au/biogs/EM00083b.htm
- Australian Architectural Index File. Record 12467, Registration 2347.The Argus, 10 Mar 1880, page 2
- Australian Architectural Index file. M. Egan, Melbourne, wins award at the International Exhibition for architectural drawings. Argus20.5.1881 (Int. Ex.supplement, p 62)
- Australian Architectural Index. Record 35524. The Argus, 20 Apr 1883, page 6.
- Williamstown Historical Society archives
- Hobsons Bay Council Heritage Study
- Victorian Heritage database - https://vhd.heritagecouncil.vic.gov.au/search?kw=No.+2+Treasury+place&aut_off=1
Our stories









